He’s been there since the very start, and yet for all he’s worth and his legacy, somehow it’s not entirely clear thatBatmanis among the few superheroes that can truly do it all by himself. See, while the Justice League and other superhero team-ups may leave Bruce Wayne looking like a regular human with just the right tools, in film only Spider-Man can challengeBatman.
That unique superpower is one DC has been flaunting since the golden and silver ages of comics, thus resulting in 1943’s first attempt to adaptBatmaninto other media in a lesser-known theatrical serial. Then, of course, the sixties saw the release of a pop culture icon when Adam West and Burt Ward suited up in 1966 to star in the TV series that would defineBatmanfor many decades.
RELATED:Why Batman’s Love Interests Don’t WorkDespite being shamelessly campy and a far cry from what Batman is today, the TV series from the sixties and its accompanying movie proved that whenever there was new ground to be broken for superheroes, Batman had to be at the forefront. After going on break and leavingSupermanto cement the notion that superhero movies could be huge, Tim Burton’sBatmanchanged the game forever by adding a level of artistry to his Gotham that wassimply not possible in Clark Kent’s world.
What Makes The Batman Formula Work
The biggest contribution Burton made inBatmanwas introducing him as a gritty, moody, and overall darker superhero, a stark contrast to Superman and practically everything Marvel had to offer back then. This spin was not conceived by Burton on his own, but instead inspired by Frank Miller’s work onThe Dark Knight Returnscomics to create the Batman persona most recognized by modern fans, one that was burdened by the weight of his own sense of duty.
See, Miller didn’t rely on Batman calling his Justice League buddies for help to save the day because he was already an interesting enough protagonist, on top of having an equally impressive collection of villains and friends to choose from. AsJames Gunn recently put it, DC heroes excel at living in their individual stories with the rare crossover eventually taking place; whereas in Marvel characters tend to have a greater awareness of each other’s existence, perhaps due to New York City’s unusually high number of superheroes per capita.
The reason for that is the same that made theArkhamvideo games so successful, that Batman’s world can be immersive enough to forget he has other superhero friends, one where Gotham acts like a real living city packed with crime and Bruce struggles with problems other godlike heroes rarely have. At the same time, Batman’s sole power is still more attainable than any other superheroes, he’s just filthy rich, so he’ll always be more “grounded” than most of his peers and that’s part of what makes him special and almost impossible to imitate.
If It Ain’t Broke, Don’t Fix It
The one event that changed the landscape for the superhero film genre was Tony Stark escaping captivity with an arc reactor stuck to his chest, and it wasn’t thatIron Manwas a threat toBatmanbut rather because of the never-before-seen success achieved whenThe Avengersassembled in 2012 and 2015. Marvel’s MCU was conceived as a Hail Mary plan, basically, it was the only way the studio could save itself without its ownBatman, givenSpider-Manand theX-Menwere busy making money for other studios.
Of course, it helps thatIron Manis a great entertaining movie, but every other entry that came beforeThe Avengersis generally considered worse, and yet they instilled in DC’s camps the desire and need to come up with something just as good and thus the need for a newBatman to succeed Christian Bale. So DC Films decided to go against the 50-year precedent that dictated solo Batman was a proven winner to make him co-star alongside Superman inDawn of Justice.
Nevertheless, even if that clash has plenty of comics source material, the main problem lied in having it be about a Batman audiences didn’t know, hence it was the same Caped Crusader but without many of the things that had normally made the franchise a hit, including his villains. It was all proof that the DCEU clearly didn’t have a smooth path to play catch up with Marvel and bringing in Joss Whedon to put some MCU touches on 2017’sJustice Leagueonly robbed that film of whatever identity had been built by Snyder.
It’s a blessing for fans that Matt Reeves’The Batmanexists within a world exclusive to himself, because there are no other movies to nod at, nothing to set up, just pure good old Bruce Wayne. Like his Batman-only predecessor, Christopher Nolan, Reeves only has to work to tell the bestlengthy Batman story he can come up with, and the fact that he chose a Miller saga likeYear Oneas one of his main sources of inspiration already gives off plenty Burton vibes.
Reeves’ Gotham was created as its own ecosystem, there’s no Metropolis to compare it to as there are no other superheroes to compare Batman’s fighting skills and his lack of superpowers. A lone Batman is one that can lean in further tohis fame as the world’s greatest detective, and that’s ultimately a winning formula that doesn’t share too much with the rest of the superhero films being made today and that’s certainly not a bad thing.
The Batmanwill be released exclusively in theaters on May 25, 2025.
