With a somewhat barebones content update coming toRed Dead Onlinefor Halloween, and nothing major coming to theRed Dead Redemption 2story mode, it seems like fan requests forUndead Nightmare 2have gone unheard by Rockstar Games. With their hopes dashed, fans ofRed Dead 2took to Reddit to muse over the potential that expansion may have had.

Thelegacy of the firstUndead Nightmare, as well as Rockstar’s other single-player DLC, has lingered. Fans have not forgotten the original expansion for the firstRed Deadgame, which not only brought zombies to the game, but a redesigned map and a completely new story to experience. However, withRed Dead 2following inGTA 5’s footsteps and adding no single-player DLC whatsoever, the hopes for ever seeing a similar expansion seem dead.

RELATED:Red Dead Redemption 2’s Morality System Feels Redundant, But It Really Isn’t

Despite one member of Rockstar’s team saying the studio hadno plans forUndead NightmarecontentinRed Dead Redemption 2late last year, fans kept hope alive as long as they could. With this Halloween 2020 update, however, it seems like players are finally done holding onto the hope for single-player DLC forRed Dead Redemption 2. In a post to the RDR2 subreddit, reddit user xsiens made a post titled “missed opportunity for rdr2 undead nightmare” so that fans could share their thoughts.

Attached to the post is fan art showing an undead Arthur Morgan, something that would no doubt be a big draw. Withfans layingUndead Nightmare 2to rest, though, the post’s replies are mostly negative and share disgust or disappointment. One user, goregasm, said they will dust off the PS3 and play the originalUndead Nightmare. NielHL believes the DLC is never coming as well, and if it did it would “just be an online add on” as opposed to an actual single-player expansion. Benjismalls asks, “Why does Rockstar hate story mode players,” before getting the reply from pandamcbearface2211 saying those fans “buy the game and don’t give them more money.”

Thezombies added toRed Dead Onlinewill likely be the closest players get to a properUndead Nightmarefollow-up, a situation memed by Betito117. The player references the “my disappointment is immeasurable” meme before saying their “heart is broken once again,” a message echoed by TsushimasDeath, who simply wants to “yeet zombies.” The rest of the comments point toGTA Onlineas the source of blame forRed Dead Redemption 2’s lack of support, a belief held by many players.

With runningbread888_yt angered that “R* refuses to let gta5 die” and BoxOfLasers calling theGTA 5updates “low effort,” it seems many fans are angry at Rockstar’s other open world game. WithRockstar forgettingGTA Online’s anniversary, though, perhaps players for both games have reason to be frustrated with the developer.

Red Dead Redemption 2is available now on PC, PS4, Stadia, and Xbox One.

MORE:Red Dead Redemption 2 Player Discovers Touching Moment With John Marston