A talentedAnimal Crossing: New Horizonsfan is quickly gaining attention from other players after posting photos of some impressive Brewster-themed cookie keychains. Utilizing some impressive photography skills and a thought-out picture composition, the cookie keychains look impressive enough to be added as a menu item in Brewster’s cafe itself.

For those who may be unaware, Brewster is a rather quiet, aloof pigeon who is about all things coffee, and runs a 24-hour cafe called The Roost. Largely serving the same capacity in everyAnimal Crossingentry sinceAnimal Crossing: Wild World, the Gyroid-loving character offers characters a daily cup of coffee for 200 Bells. Brewster becomes available after completing a set of specific tasks inAnimal Crossing: New Horizons’Happy Home ParadiseDLC, which includes a plethora of other features and content.

The impressive Brewster cookie keychains come from Reddit user clancyisnotdead, who posted their creation to one of the site’s mainAnimal Crossingforums. Clearly inspired by Roost sable cookies, the treats feature The Roost’s logo thatAnimal Crossing: New Horizonsplayers will see when walking into the cafe through the museum. Accented with warm orange tones underneath, the photo’s color palette evokes a similar color scheme to the one seen in Brewster’s cafe. A cozy-looking cup of coffee in the top-left corner completes the vibe, looking like something that could actually be offered in-game.

The Brewster cookie keychain creations are clearly popular with otherAnimal Crossingfans, as the post has received well over 3,000 upvotes within just 12 hours of posting. However, they aren’t the onlyAnimal Crossingcookies making a splash on the site. While Brewster himself is omitted, another fan bakedadorable cookies of variousAnimal Crossingcharacters, including mainstays like Tom Nook, Isabelle, K.K. Slider, Blathers, and more. Unlike the ones featured above, these cookies feature brightly colored icing, but both have plenty of fan comments wishing they could be the ones to eat them.

While theAnimal Crossingfan may have created cookies that would pair well with Brewster’s coffee, one fan has taken things a step further. On the same thread, anAnimal Crossing: New Horizonsfan actually made Brewster’s coffeein real life. The creative image shows a coffee bean bag featuring The Roost’s logo, as well as a jar of milk featuring a pigeon pattern, referencing Brewster’s constant offering of pigeon milk. While it remains to be confirmed if the Brewster cookie keychains are legitimately edible, they look like they would pair well with the fan-made coffee.

While the Brewster-themed coffee and cookies are fan-made,Animal Crossing: New Horizonsfans can actually get some official merchandise inspired by the cafe. Nintendo’s loyalty programMy Nintendo Rewards is offering official Brewster coasters, which feature the same logo as the fan-made cookies and coffee.

Animal Crossing: New Horizonsis available exclusively on Nintendo Switch.

MORE:The Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack is Inconsistent with its DLC Offerings